When You're Right, You're Right

Emily Jones is always right - just ask her. When her blunt honesty fixes her dad's chili recipe, she's sure her judgment can fix anything, so she leaps from the bushes to defend her brother Barrett from Jay Smouse... and mortifies him instead. Then she learns Barrett has asked Matthew to build a musical birthday card for Priscilla, complete with his own trombone playing and a silly recorded message. Certain she knows romance better than any boy, Emily orders Matthew to swap out the music and deepen Barrett's voice. But when Priscilla laughs, hugs Barrett, and loves the goofy card exactly as he made it, Matthew confesses he secretly changed everything back. Emily heads home humbled, learning over a bowl of new-and-improved chili that even when you're sure you're right, wisdom means asking whether it's truly best - or just your idea.

Found on Take It from the Top Album 51 · 12 episodes

The run See every episode

1 of 2 0655 The Inspiration Station When Whit's new invention shows people their best selves, Connie's newfound serenity and Matthew's well-meaning tinkering both spiral into trouble at Whit's End.

2 of 2 0656 The Inspiration Station When a machine at Whit's End offers instant inspiration, Whit must help a discouraged young inventor and an over-eager Connie discover what real growth actually requires.

0657 Clutter A family garage sale grinds to a halt when every Parker discovers that nothing they own is quite easy to let go.

0658 Game for a Mystery When a boy's beloved handheld game vanishes from its hiding spot, an aspiring young detective takes on her very first case.

0659 Target of the Week When Matthew becomes the school bully's designated victim for a week, he decides to stop being afraid and get even - with consequences he never saw coming.

0660 For the Birds When Camilla rescues an orphaned baby blue jay to prove she's ready for a pet of her own, she discovers responsibility demands far more than she imagined - while Eugene wages a baffling battle with the park's suddenly hostile birds.

0661 When You're Right, You're Right Certain she knows best, Emily takes charge of her brother's romantic gesture - whether he wants her help or not.

0662 Grandma's Visit When Grandma Lucia arrives in Odyssey with news that Aunt Rosalita's wedding will happen at the Parker home that very week, the family's frantic hospitality is stretched to its breaking point.

0663 Finish What You... When Olivia takes up guitar lessons, a preschool play, and a birthday promise all at once, she discovers that good intentions alone can't stretch her time far enough.

1 of 3 0664 The Jubilee Singers When Olivia dismisses school as pointless, a portrait of Frederick Douglass introduces her to the students of a struggling university whose only hope may be the songs they carry.

2 of 3 0665 The Jubilee Singers A Fisk choir and their determined director set out on a perilous tour to sing their school out of debt, facing hostility and hardship at every stop.

3 of 3 0666 The Jubilee Singers With Fisk University on the brink of collapse, a weary group of student singers must decide whether to keep performing on a grueling tour that has cost them their health, their dignity, and nearly all hope.

1 of 2 0667 The Mystery of the Clock Tower When City Hall's computerized clock mysteriously keeps resetting itself to 11:45, Eugene's investigation uncovers black roses, a warning note, and a twenty-year-old secret someone in Odyssey has kept hidden.

Featured characters

Minor characters & crew 3 more roles

3 supporting roles

Simon Jones Joel McCrary Priscilla Peterson Gatlin Green Card Voice Dave Arnold

Made by

Chris Anthony Host Kirby Atkins Writer Paul McCusker Writer Dave Arnold Director · Executive Producer Nathan Jones Sound Designer Bob Hoose Producer

The story

Read the full synopsis 2 min

Emily's father asks her to judge a new chili recipe, and she bluntly explains that mixing cornmeal into the pot ruins the crunch of corn chips and that he has used far too little chili powder. Simon appreciates her honesty and changes the recipe. Matthew is surprised by her directness, but Emily says straightforward truth is a form of respect in her family.

On the way to the store, Emily and Matthew hide in some bushes to watch Barrett walk home with Priscilla Peterson. When Jay Smouse teases Barrett, Emily leaps out and delivers a fierce speech in her brother's defense. Barrett is not grateful. He is embarrassed that she has spied on his private conversation, announced his feelings for Priscilla, and treated him as if he could not handle Jay himself.

Emily soon discovers that Barrett has asked Matthew to build a special musical birthday card for Priscilla. It combines Barrett's trombone playing with a silly message he recorded himself. Convinced that she understands romance better than either boy, Emily orders Matthew to replace Barrett's music and alter his voice to sound deeper. Matthew objects, but Emily refuses to consider that she might be wrong.

Emily hides near Barrett and Priscilla again to watch the card being delivered. Priscilla opens it, laughs, and hugs Barrett. Emily proudly takes credit for the success - until Barrett thanks Matthew for making his original trombone recording sound so good.

Matthew admits that he changed Emily's version back. Altering the card without Barrett's knowledge would have ignored what Barrett actually wanted, and Matthew knew Emily would not listen if he warned her. Priscilla has liked Barrett's funny, genuine gift precisely as he created it.

Emily returns home humbled. Simon's corrected chili now has the right balance of spice and crunch, and he explains that his first attempt failed because he was trying so hard to be clever that he overlooked what the dish needed. Emily sees the same imbalance in herself. Her intelligence, passion, and willingness to act are strengths, but they require wisdom and discernment. Even when she feels certain she is right, she must stop and ask whether she wants something because it is truly best or merely because it is her idea.