The run See every episode
Featured characters
Minor characters & crew 8 more roles
The story
Read the full synopsis 4 min
At Whit's End, Connie arrives with her half-sister Jules to find the front of the shop freshly repainted. Whit explains that someone pelted the building with paint-filled balloons, and he and Jason spent the whole evening covering the mess. Dale Jacobs from the newspaper hurries in with troubling news: Detective Polehouse believes Whit was deliberately targeted. Whit admits that Miss Adelaide from the school asked him to hang a poster for the upcoming Let's Get Together Festival, a celebration of tolerance and inclusivity, and that he politely declined. Dale points out that the paint colors match those used by a group from Connellsville called the Vigilantors. Jules has heard of them from California and warns that they usually don't stop until they get what they want.
At school, Emily tells Matthew she has just seen Katrina Meltsner registering Buck Oliver for classes. Jay bursts in and reacts with alarm, wondering whether Buck has broken out of jail and immediately checking for his wallet. Buck himself walks up, tells them he is truly sorry for everything he did and for hurting them, and asks them to forgive him, before heading off to find his locker. The kids are left stunned, and Jay announces he is taking home all his valuables anyway.
Meanwhile, Connie and Jules visit Jason's antique shop, where Jason has finally opened the lock on the old trunk that came with Connie's things from her mother. Inside, Connie finds stacks of her own school papers, tests, and art projects going all the way back to kindergarten, and a note taped inside the lid: "For Connie, when she has kids." Jules can't understand why anyone would save all that, and Connie answers simply, "Because she's my mom." Afterward Jules grows quiet, and when Connie gently asks if something is on her mind, Jules deflects. She admits she sees a therapist every week with her mother, supposedly because she has issues, though the sessions are mostly spent on her mom's problems. When Connie offers to listen, Jules says she really doesn't want to talk, and Connie lets it go.
At Wooton's house, his cousin Hadley keeps trying to help with Wooton's new comic, the Sleuth Family Robinsons, even though Wooton prefers to brainstorm alone. Hadley reminds him of the publishing offer from Dee Grant of Maximized Comics and insists that comics are his whole life, but mostly he just keeps knocking things over. Later, at Hal's Diner, Penny tells Wooton that the mysterious blogger called the Perilous Pen has published everything from his big announcement, including photos of his sketch, and has promised more to come. Penny presses Wooton about whether his artwork and character notes are safely hidden, and then raises an uncomfortable idea: what if Hadley himself is the Perilous Pen? Wooton protests that Hadley is family, but he has to admit that comics are a ruthless business.
In Miss Adelaide's class, the students learn they must write a series of essays for the festival about how people are intolerant and exclude others. The first essay asks what difference it makes whether we're men or women, and it is due the very next day. That assignment ruins Jay's plan to drag Matthew and Emily out to Hangman's Hollow, a spooky spot in the woods where a stranger has been buying up antiques for a ghost town. Jay vows to bust the mystery wide open without them and recruits another boy instead.
Matthew and Emily wrestle with what forgiving Buck really means. Emily decides forgiving him doesn't mean they have to trust him yet, but they invite him to walk with them to Whit's End. Along the way they warn him about Vance, the boy who invited Buck to sit with him at lunch, explaining that Vance doesn't have friends, only people he uses. Buck thanks them and says he is trying for a new life and doesn't want anything to spoil it. Emily tells him they're okay to start from here, and Buck gladly accepts that.
Detective Polehouse pays a visit to Miss Adelaide and questions her about the paint attack on Whit's End. She insists he has no evidence and suggests that people simply get passionate about social justice. The detective answers that vandalism for any cause is illegal and tells her to warn her friends that their coercion isn't welcome in Odyssey. Unbothered, she offers him a festival poster for the police station, remarking that the building could use the color.
That evening, Wooton and Penny return to Wooton's house and find it completely ransacked. They discover Hadley on the floor of the studio with a cut on his forehead. He says he came back from a walk, surprised a man in black wearing a ski mask, and was knocked down. The intruder ignored the valuables and took Wooton's artwork instead, and Hadley believes it was the Perilous Pen. Wooton is left with one horrified thought: "He knows where I live!"











